Why It Feels So Hard to Leave Your Baby With Someone Else: Understanding Postpartum Anxiety
Learn why leaving your baby feels so hard for many moms. A therapist explains postpartum anxiety, intrusive thoughts, and how to feel safe again.
If you’ve ever debated whether it’s “okay” to leave your baby with someone else — even someone you trust — you’re not alone. One of my posts went viral this week because thousands of moms related to the same thought:
“My anxiety tells me no one else can keep my baby safe like I can.”
For many mothers, this isn’t just a passing worry. It’s a daily mental battle between wanting a break and feeling terrified something might go wrong if they’re not physically there.
If this resonates with you, you’re not dramatic. You’re not overprotective.
This is a very real sign of postpartum anxiety, and it’s far more common than most moms realize.
Let’s talk about why this happens — and why it makes perfect sense.
Postpartum Anxiety Changes the Way Your Brain Processes Safety
After you have a baby, your brain becomes biologically wired to scan for danger. This is a survival mechanism.
But for many moms, especially those with postpartum anxiety, this protective instinct becomes overwhelming. Your brain starts sending signals like:
“What if something happens when I’m not there?”
“What if they don’t know how to soothe my baby?”
“What if they forget to check on them?”
“What if something goes wrong and I’m too far away?”
Your nervous system responds as if these possibilities are guarantees — even when your logical mind knows your baby will be safe.
This is why even short separations feel big.
Why Your Anxiety Tells You “You’re the Only One Who Can Keep Them Safe”
Many moms tell me:
“I trust my partner.”
“I trust my mom.”
“I trust the babysitter.”
And yet…the anxiety still kicks in.
That’s because postpartum anxiety isn’t about trust. It’s about perceived control.
Here’s why it feels so intense:
1. You are the one who knows your baby best.
You know their cries, their cues, their quirks.
You know their routines and what calms them.
Your brain interprets this as:
“Only I know how to keep them safe.”
2. Your nervous system is overloaded.
Sleep deprivation + hormones + responsibility = heightened anxiety, even in safe situations.
3. Moms carry the mental load.
Appointments, feedings, nap schedules, safety reminders — it’s all stored in your brain.
Letting someone else take over feels like letting go of control… and that’s scary when you’re already overwhelmed.
4. Intrusive thoughts make everything feel more dangerous.
These thoughts are common in postpartum anxiety:
worst-case scenarios
“what if” fears
sudden mental images you don’t want
They’re not predictions. They’re anxiety symptoms.
5. Society tells moms they’re “the default parent.”
When the world tells you you’re the one who should carry everything…
you start believing you have to.
You’re Not Overreacting. You’re Overloaded
One of the biggest myths about early motherhood is that you should instantly feel confident leaving your baby.
But the truth is:
Separation anxiety is NORMAL for moms and especially normal for moms with postpartum anxiety.
Your body isn't trying to punish you. It’s trying to protect you and your baby. It just hasn’t realized yet that you’re allowed to rest too.
Signs This Might Be Postpartum Anxiety (Not Just “New Mom Worry”)
If you notice yourself experiencing any of the following, it might be more than typical worry:
Feeling panic or dread at the idea of leaving your baby
Checking in constantly when you do leave
Feeling unable to relax even when your baby is safe
Overthinking worst-case scenarios
Feeling guilty for wanting time to yourself
Tightness in your chest, racing heart, or restlessness
Feeling like something bad will happen the moment you step away
These are all common symptoms of postpartum anxiety — and they are treatable.
So How Do You Start Feeling Safe Again?
Healing doesn’t mean you’ll suddenly stop caring about your baby’s safety. It means your nervous system will stop sounding the alarm when there’s no danger.
Here are the first steps:
1. Talk about it.
Anxiety grows in silence. Naming your fear is the beginning of loosening its grip.
2. Start with small separations.
Even 10 minutes with someone you trust helps your brain learn:
“They’re safe even when I’m not in the room.”
3. Explore the root of the fear.
Is it control? Fear of judgement? Fear of something happening? A therapist can help you unpack this safely.
4. Work with a trained perinatal therapist.
Postpartum anxiety is highly treatable with:
CBT
grounding
cognitive reframing
nervous system regulation
You don’t have to feel this way forever.
You Deserve Breaks. You Deserve Peace. You Deserve Support.
If leaving your baby feels impossible, please know this:
You are not the only mom who feels this way.
You are not “too attached.”
You’re overwhelmed and your body is asking for support.
Your baby is safest with a mom who feels safe too.
Help is available
〰️
Help is available 〰️
If this resonated with you, or if anxiety has been stealing the joy from your motherhood experience, I’m here to help.
I specialize in postpartum anxiety, birth trauma, and early motherhood support — and offer virtual therapy for moms across New Jersey.
👉 Read more postpartum resources on my blog
👉 Book a free 15-minute consultation
👉 Join a support group with other likeminded moms
You deserve a motherhood that feels lighter. And healing is absolutely possible.